Say Her Name is, as you’ve probably figured out, a horror story about a very popular urban legend that just happens to be one of my favourites. Bloody Mary is also one of my favourite (and one of the scariest) episodes of Supernatural, so I couldn’t not request this book when I got the offer. As promised, Say Her Name is a creepy read that almost has the classic horror story feel to it.
It was very, very creepy in the beginning, with the mirrors and the (stupid) characters saying Bloody Mary in front of a mirror. Just… WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT?! I have messed around with ouija boards and all sorts of things, but I absolutely refuse to say it. There was also a hint of another urban legend – you know, the dripping one? “Humans can lick too”? That one also gives me nightmares because I can’t stand home invasion stories. Or killing dogs. Anyway…
I didn’t really care for any of the characters in Say Her Name, which was a shame, but also true of a lot of horror stories. The horror aspect is usually a lot more enticing and well thought out than the characters who are involved in the game.
As a result of this, I didn’t give a crap about the romance. In fact, I found it very irritating. Can we stop creating romances when the story is a horror? Or, better yet, flesh out the romance a bit more and make the book a bit longer. I had the same issue with Ten by Gretchen McNeil. If I’m signing up for a horror story, I don’t expect to see insta-love or mushy romance. I’m here for the deaths! *cough* Scream did romance very well, for example, and it’s a shame that few horror novels manage to pull stuff like that off.
The writing was good, but nothing outstanding. It was an to read because I couldn’t wait to see what the death count would be by the end of the book, and the writing is simple and quick to read. However, Bobbie’s best friend says “Gurl”, “gurrrrrrl”, “girl” (and other variations, but you get the idea) about fifty times, and it’s bloody frustrating! I thought it was also very stereotypical because Naya is originally from the USA. It was totally unnecessary.
I really liked James Dawson’s use of flashbacks to develop the plot and the mystery surrounding Bloody Mary. I thought that these flashbacks made it really obvious as to what happened to Mary, but apparently the characters had a much harder time figuring it out. But the link that was created between past from present was interesting, and it felt very Supernatural.
My favourite part of the book, of course, was the ending. It was a classic horror movie ending, with an “oh shit” realisation at the very end as you’re closing the book.
If you’re looking for a quick horror read, then I would recommend Say Her Name because I love urban legends. But if you’re looking for anything that’s in-depth then you’re probably looking in the wrong place. Say Her Name was a great retelling of an urban legend, and, like I said, some parts were very creepy!